Inside Real Estate – Episode 21 – Off Market Sales Pros & Cons – September 2019

Tips & Advice

Inside Real Estate – Episode 21 – Off Market Sales Pros & Cons – September 2019

Inside Real Estate with Doug Buenz, episode 21: Off-Market Sales Pros & Cons, over a home at dusk.

 

Inside Real Estate – Episode 21

 

Off-Market Sales Pros & Cons

 
What is an off-market sale? An off-market sale is simply a property that sells before or without going on the multiple listing service (MLS). Therefore, it is not freely available to the entire marketplace.
 
What is the benefit to a seller for an off-market sale? The big benefit is convenience. They do not have to hassle with getting their house ready. You are not putting in new carpet or paint or doing any work. It is simple: buyer walks in, buyer makes an offer, seller accepts it, and you have an off-market sale.
 
What’s the benefit to a buyer? In extreme competitive market, buyers often like off-market sales because there is no competition. They have a better chance of getting the home that they want without the fear of competing against multiple offers.
 
The interesting thing is there is risk associated with off-market sales. The risk spreads both ways. There is risk to the seller and there is risk to the buyer.
 
The seller might be leaving money on the table. It is possible that had they listed their property on the MLS and done a couple of the things that would enhance its value, they could have sold for more money. So that is always the risk for a seller. They do not know if they are leaving money on the table or not.
 
The risk of the buyer in an off-market sale is they may be overpaying. The house has not had a chance to get market tested, so the buyer really has no frame of reference as to how the property is doing in the marketplace.
 
It is possible the buyer is going to pay a premium on an off-market sale. It is possible the seller may be leaving money on the table.
 
Let me give you an example of some of the pitfalls of an off-market sale. Recently here in Pleasanton, there was a home that was on the market and an off-market sale came out. The off-market sale was published after the newly listed home was on the market. The off-market sale was $100,000 higher than the current home on the market.
 
Theoretically, the off-market buyer paid $100,000 more than what they could have if the house had been listed on the market. The house on the market, by the way, was a nicer house. It had a pool, more upgrades. In this case, you can make a strong argument, the buyer overpaid for the off-market property. Because they bought it off-market, they did not have a chance for the market to test and respond to this property. Putting your home on the market allows you to get a gauge on its relative value to buyers today.
 
If you are a buyer you need to be cautious and understand you may not have a good read on the value of that property. If you are a seller, it is possible you might be selling it too cheap. That might be worth the convenience factor, it might not. That is a decision you will have to make. Those are the ins and outs of off-market sales.
 
If you know someone who would benefit from this information, please do share it with them. And if we can help you with any of your real estate needs, please call us at 925-621-0680 or see us at 680homes.com
 
This is Doug Buenz with 680homes.com and the latest episode of Inside Real Estate. Our topic is “c”
 
What is an off-market sale? An off-market sale is simply a property that sells before or without going on the multiple listing service (MLS). Therefore, it is not freely available to the entire marketplace.
 
What is the benefit to a seller for an off-market sale? The big benefit is convenience. They do not have to hassle with getting their house ready. You are not putting in new carpet or paint or doing any work. It is simple: buyer walks in, buyer makes an offer, seller accepts it, and you have an off-market sale.
 
What’s the benefit to a buyer? In extreme competitive market, buyers often like off-market sales because there is no competition. They have a better chance of getting the home that they want without the fear of competing against multiple offers.
 
The interesting thing is there is risk associated with off-market sales. The risk spreads both ways. There is risk to the seller and there is risk to the buyer.
 
The seller might be leaving money on the table. It is possible that had they listed their property on the MLS and done a couple of the things that would enhance its value, they could have sold for more money. So that is always the risk for a seller. They do not know if they are leaving money on the table or not.
 
The risk of the buyer in an off-market sale is they may be overpaying. The house has not had a chance to get market tested, so the buyer really has no frame of reference as to how the property is doing in the marketplace.
 
It is possible the buyer is going to pay a premium on an off-market sale. It is possible the seller may be leaving money on the table.
 
Let me give you an example of some of the pitfalls of an off-market sale. Recently here in Pleasanton, there was a home that was on the market and an off-market sale came out. The off-market sale was published after the newly listed home was on the market. The off-market sale was $100,000 higher than the current home on the market.
 
Theoretically, the off-market buyer paid $100,000 more than what they could have if the house had been listed on the market. The house on the market, by the way, was a nicer house. It had a pool, more upgrades. In this case, you can make a strong argument, the buyer overpaid for the off-market property. Because they bought it off-market, they did not have a chance for the market to test and respond to this property. Putting your home on the market allows you to get a gauge on its relative value to buyers today.
 
If you are a buyer you need to be cautious and understand you may not have a good read on the value of that property. If you are a seller, it is possible you might be selling it too cheap. That might be worth the convenience factor, it might not. That is a decision you will have to make. Those are the ins and outs of off-market sales.
 
If you know someone who would benefit from this information, please do share it with them. And if we can help you with any of your real estate needs, please call us at 925-785-7777 or see us at 680homes.com

Recent Blog Posts

Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.

West Pleasanton market update with data as of November 3, 2026 showing 2 active listings, 1 pending sale, 6 closed sales and 1.0 months of supply for single-family homes over 1,600 square feet

Market Update

West Pleasanton Real Estate Market Update November 2026

Doug Buenz  |  November 11, 2026

About one month of supply, six closings and a clear price-per-foot ceiling for homes over 1,600 sq ft

Pleasanton luxury real estate market update for October 2026, featuring an aerial neighborhood view and statistics for homes over $3 million: 9 active listings, 3 pending sales, and 3 closed sales.

Pleasanton luxury real estate

Pleasanton Luxury Real Estate Market Update: October 2026

Doug Buenz  |  October 23, 2026

Two distinct markets: Limited inventory below $4 million, more choices at higher prices, and why strategic pricing matters.

South Livermore luxury market update for October 2026, with active, pending, and sold listings.

South Livermore

South Livermore Luxury Market Update for October 2026

Doug Buenz  |  October 22, 2026

Seven luxury homes are on the market in South Livermore, with no pending sales. Four closings show how time on market relates to sale-to-list results.

Dublin luxury real estate market update for October 2026, featuring an aerial neighborhood view and statistics for homes over $2 million: 17 active listings, 3 pending sales, and 5 sold homes.

Tri-Valley real estate

Dublin Luxury Real Estate Market Update October 2026

Doug Buenz  |  October 21, 2026

Seventeen active listings and five closings highlight the importance of property specific pricing

Dublin market update for September 2026: inventory has leveled off, and pricing precision matters.

Market Update

Dublin Real Estate Market Update | September 2026

Doug Buenz  |  October 16, 2026

Inventory has leveled off, buyer activity has slowed, and accurate pricing is becoming increasingly important.

Livermore market update for September 2026, with an aerial view of homes and surrounding hills.

Market Update

Livermore Real Estate Market Update | September 2026

Doug Buenz  |  October 12, 2026

Inventory has leveled off, buyer activity has slowed, and strategic pricing continues to shape results.

Pleasanton real estate market update for September 2026, with an aerial neighborhood view and 680 Group and Compass branding.

Market Update

Pleasanton Real Estate Market Update | September 2026

Doug Buenz  |  October 9, 2026

Well-priced homes are selling quickly, while longer market times give buyers more negotiating room.

Dublin September 2026 real estate market update showing 133 active, 52 pending, and 52 sold listings.

Market Update

Dublin Real Estate Market Update September 2026

Doug Buenz  |  September 21, 2026

Inventory remains elevated, absorption stays below 40%, and Dublin buyers are separating well-positioned homes from listings that miss the market.

Livermore real estate market update for September 2026, with an aerial view of vineyards and homes and housing statistics.

Market Update

Livermore Real Estate Market Update | September 2026

Doug Buenz  |  September 19, 2026

Pricing Precision Shapes the Early Fall Market

Work With Us

Follow Us on Instagram