Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Inside Real Estate – Episode 15 – How Accurate Are Online Valuations? – May 2019

Tips & Advice

Inside Real Estate – Episode 15 – How Accurate Are Online Valuations? – May 2019

 
 
Inside Real Estate “How Accurate Are Online Valuations?
 
Everybody’s favorite hobby it seems is to go online and see what their home is worth on Zillow, and Trulia, Realtor.com, and Redfin. The question is, “How accurate are they?”
 
There is no question their accuracy has improved. Recent sales indicate that they are coming in within 2 to 4% of the sales price in a lot of cases, so that is pretty good. But you have to understand it is an algorithm. It is a mathematical formula that takes data points and analyzes those data points to arrive at a value.
 
Real estate inherently does not lend itself well to an algorithm, especially on the higher-priced homes. If you are selling a condo where there are 17 of the same floor plan that sold in the last six months, pretty good bet that the online valuation will be pretty close. If you are selling a luxury home, one of a kind with views, a lot harder to put that into an algorithm. Many of the elements of the higher-priced homes just do not lend themselves to an algorithm. They include view, privacy, amenities, lot size, usability of the lot size, floor plan, neighborhood, and interior condition. These things are essential to the value of luxury homes, and they also happen to be the hardest things to put into an algorithm. So as you go up the price chain, the online valuations get less and less reliable.
 
Now, we have an online valuation tool at 680homes.com that we feel is pretty good because you can pick and choose the sales you feel are more comparable to your property. If you visit 680homes.com and click on Instant Home Value, you will get a chance to see how that comes out for your property. We certainly invite you to do that.
 
In summary, online valuations are fun. They are fun cocktail party talk. It is fun to track your value, but when it comes time to sell, especially in the upper price ranges, so many of the value indicators are not quantifiable. That is really where you need a realtor to come out and give you an idea what the market value range of your property would be. If we can help you, or any of your friends, give us a call at (925) 785-7777, or visit our website at 680homes.com.

Recent Blog Posts

Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.

Market Update

Livermore Real Estate Market Update | September 2026

Doug Buenz  |  September 19, 2026

Pricing Precision Shapes the Early Fall Market

Market Update

Pleasanton Real Estate Market Update: Pricing Precision Defines the Early Fall Market

Doug Buenz  |  September 15, 2026

August 2026 single-family home data for Pleasanton, California, published September 2026

Dublin Real Estate Market Update: Pricing Still Matters in a Balanced Mid-Summer Market

Doug Buenz  |  August 20, 2026

Dublin’s latest single-family home trends, including inventory, buyer demand, pricing, and days on market from July 15 through August 17, 2026.

Market Update

Pleasanton Market Update: Pricing Discipline Defines Late Summer 2026

Doug Buenz  |  August 18, 2026

Pleasanton buyers have more choices, but well-priced homes can still sell at or above asking. Here’s what the latest single-family-home data means.

Market Update

South Livermore Real Estate Market Update | August 2026

Doug Buenz  |  August 18, 2026

South Livermore’s market is tight enough to reward decisive buyers, but recent closed sales show that sellers still need to price with discipline.

Market Update

Pleasanton Real Estate Market Update: August 2026

Doug Buenz  |  August 7, 2026

August 2026 Update: Well-positioned homes sold quickly and averaged 102% of asking, while homes taking over 30 days averaged just 94%.

Pleasanton Real Estate

My Pleasanton Home Didn’t Sell. Why Did My Listing Expire?

Doug Buenz  |  July 28, 2026

The most common reasons Pleasanton homes fail to attract offers—and what sellers should consider before relisting.

Market Update

Pleasanton Real Estate Market Update: June 2026

Doug Buenz  |  July 21, 2026

More Inventory, Selective Buyers, and Uneven Results for Sellers

Market Trends

Pleasanton Real Estate Market Update: Mid-July 2026

Doug Buenz  |  July 21, 2026

Single-family home activity included in the MLS snapshot from June 15 through July 20, 2026

Work With Us

Follow Us on Instagram